For a resort positioned as a five-star property, our experience at The Dunlin was extremely disappointing. I was genuinely surprised to see it awarded a Michelin Key, as our experience did not come close to reflecting the level of hospitality and service I would associate with that recognition. Beautiful aesthetics and thoughtful interior design can only take a property so far, and unfortunately, the service, cleanliness, and overall attention to detail did not live up to the standard the resort presents itself as offering. There were certainly a few bright spots, but the service overall was inconsistent and remarkably poor. The resort also fell short when it came to cleanliness, and the housekeeping was disappointing throughout our stay. Our dinner experience at Linnette’s was disappointing given that the restaurant is presented as fine dining by Auberge. The service was careless and lacked the professionalism and attention to detail I would expect at a five-star property. From wine and dishes being handled and dropped on the table without care, to repeatedly having to ask for water refills and feeling unwelcome, the experience was simply not reflective of fine dining. It was especially frustrating because the quality of service stood in such stark contrast to the beautiful setting and the expectations associated with the Auberge name. Housekeeping was another significant disappointment. The floor in our room was so dirty that our feet were black after walking around. Toilet paper would be replaced with the spare roll but not replenished, and washcloths would be removed without enough being returned. During turndown service, our door was left open after the room had been serviced, and as a result air conditioning turned off so we returned to a warm humid room. These may seem like small details, but at this level of hospitality, those details matter. That said, there were two people who genuinely stood out. Tiana at Linnette’s made our final morning breakfast a pleasure. She was welcoming, attentive, kind, and genuinely thoughtful throughout our interaction. Her service was exactly what I had hoped to experience during our stay. And Devante was, without question, the standout employee of the entire property. He greeted us when we arrived and was there to send us off on our final day. He is calm, kind, welcoming, and consistently made us feel taken care of. He embodies the level of hospitality I would expect from a five-star resort and should absolutely be an ambassador for The Dunlin and involved in customer-service training for all Dunlin employees. Ultimately, The Dunlin is undeniably beautiful. But a luxury resort is about far more than how it looks. Service, cleanliness, consistency, and attention to detail are what create a true five-star experience. Unfortunately, those elements were lacking during our stay, and the gap between the resort's five-star positioning and the experience we actually received was significant.